Mark Carney’s Immigration Policy: A Balanced Approach Amid Canada’s Challenges
As Mark Carney steps into the role of Canada’s new Prime Minister, one of the most pressing issues on his agenda is the country’s immigration system. Carney’s stance on immigration reflects a delicate balance between fostering economic growth and addressing the country’s mounting challenges, such as the housing crisis and over-reliance on international student tuition fees.
Carney has long emphasized the critical role immigration plays in strengthening Canada’s economy, yet he has also expressed concern over the current pace of immigration, questioning whether it is sustainable given the country’s infrastructure and social services.
A “Cap” on Immigration to Address Housing Pressures
In a bold proposal aimed at alleviating Canada’s housing crisis, Carney has suggested introducing a “cap” on immigration until the country can return to a pre-pandemic, sustainable immigration trend. According to policy documents unveiled in February 2025, this cap would be a corrective measure to slow down immigration inflows that Carney believes are currently overwhelming Canada’s housing, healthcare, and social service systems.
“We’ve allowed too many foreign workers, students, and new Canadians to enter without the necessary infrastructure to support them,” Carney stated in a November 2024 speech. “We don’t have the housing, healthcare, or opportunities to accommodate this influx.”
Carney’s proposal calls for a more restrained immigration policy than the one seen in recent years, particularly during the pandemic when Canada significantly ramped up its immigration targets to address labor shortages.
Prioritizing Temporary Residents for Permanent Residency
Carney’s proposed immigration policies also focus on the issue of temporary residents. He advocates for prioritizing the transition of temporary residents to permanent residency status, a move in line with recent policy shifts by Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC). In fact, Carney’s emphasis on absorbing the over 4 million temporary residents currently in Canada mirrors the direction outlined in the latest Immigration Levels Plan, which targets a significant portion of permanent residency admissions for those already residing in Canada.
Carney suggested that before focusing on growth, Canada must first address the needs of the population already within its borders.
Tackling the Influx of Temporary Foreign Workers
Another key component of Carney’s immigration agenda is addressing the rising number of temporary foreign workers (TFWs) in Canada. He acknowledges that the government failed to properly manage the flow of TFWs during the COVID-19 pandemic when businesses ramped up hiring to meet labor shortages.
Carney’s concern about the unchecked rise of TFWs is reflected in his criticism of Canada’s reliance on temporary workers to fill essential roles. While the Immigration Levels Plan for 2025-27 sets limits on work permits, Carney advocates for a more careful and deliberate approach to TFW admissions, arguing that it’s time to reduce the reliance on temporary labor and focus on permanent residents who can better integrate into Canadian society.
Addressing the Financial Burden of International Students
In addition to managing immigration levels, Carney has raised concerns about the financial pressure international students place on Canada’s higher education system. He has pointed out that many Canadian universities have become overly dependent on international student tuition fees to remain financially viable, especially as provincial funding has stagnated. This reliance has led to significant fiscal challenges for many institutions, some of which have had to cut programs and implement layoffs.
Carney advocates for increased government funding to support postsecondary institutions, arguing that this would reduce their dependency on international student tuition and ease the financial strain on students and educational institutions alike.
Housing Crisis: A Top Priority
Carney’s immigration agenda is inextricably linked to his broader approach to solving Canada’s housing crisis. As part of his plan to combat the country’s housing shortages, Carney has promised to invest in the construction sector by expanding training and apprenticeship programs for skilled trades workers. His policy aims to boost housing construction capacity and provide more affordable housing options for Canadians, especially as the immigration cap is implemented.
While Carney has yet to clarify whether he supports direct federal funding for public housing, his focus on the construction sector aligns with ongoing government initiatives to create new pathways for construction workers to immigrate to Canada.
Immigration and Canada’s National Identity
Carney remains committed to the belief that immigration is essential to Canada’s economic prosperity and national identity. Despite proposing a more measured approach to immigration, he has reaffirmed his support for Canada’s long-standing tradition of welcoming immigrants. He has emphasized that immigration has been integral to Canada’s development, with a significant portion of the population being either immigrants or second-generation Canadians.
“We are a country built on immigration, and it is crucial for our future success,” Carney noted. “We must find a balance between welcoming newcomers and ensuring we have the resources to support them.”
Mark Carney’s Background
Carney brings a wealth of experience to his role as Prime Minister. Raised in Edmonton, Alberta, Carney studied economics at Harvard University and went on to earn advanced degrees from the University of Oxford. His career spans decades of leadership in global financial institutions, including Goldman Sachs, the Bank of Canada, and the Bank of England. From 2020 onward, Carney worked as the UN Special Envoy for Climate Action and Finance while also serving as chair of Brookfield Asset Management.
Carney’s deep knowledge of economics and finance has shaped his approach to Canada’s immigration policies, which prioritize long-term sustainability while addressing immediate challenges like housing and labor shortages.
What’s Next for Mark Carney?
As Carney prepares to take office, questions remain about the timeline for his proposed policies. While Canada’s next federal election must occur by October 20, 2025, it’s possible that an early election may be triggered by a no-confidence vote, which could determine the speed at which Carney can implement his immigration reforms.
Carney’s leadership is expected to reshape Canada’s immigration landscape, with a focus on ensuring that immigration supports both economic growth and the country’s ability to provide for its growing population.
For a consultation about Immigration options, reach out to the CAD IMMIGRATION today!
